Side-by-side comparison

AXP vs PGR — Side-by-side comparison

PGR screens cheaper on EV/FCF, PGR has the higher ROIC, PGR has grown revenue faster over five years, and Neither has the cleaner balance sheet by net debt / EBITDA.

AXP

American Express

Price

$311.78

Market cap

$194.8B

Day %

N/A

PGR

Progressive Corp.

Price

$199.51

Market cap

$165.4B

Day %

N/A

Peer Comparison

Target stock against 1 market-cap comparable peer.

Heat map: red worst to green best


AXP Target	American Express	$194.8B	20.3x	12.7x	12.1%	13.5%	38.7%	N/A	N/A	N/A
PGR	Progressive Corp.	$165.4B	10.4x	9.6x	37.3%	15.5%	19.6%	N/A	N/A	N/A

AXP implied-growth snapshot

Simple static valuation context using owner earnings yield and realized growth.

EV/FCF

12.7x

FCF yield

8.2%

5Y rev CAGR

13.5%

PGR implied-growth snapshot

Simple static valuation context using owner earnings yield and realized growth.

EV/FCF

9.6x

FCF yield

10.4%

5Y rev CAGR

15.5%

5Y indexed stock chart

Static Recharts view indexed to 100 from available annual per-share data.

Quality Scorecard

Build-time composite score for AXP.

Grade C

/ 100

Quality Radar0 – 20 per axis

Quality Scorecard

Build-time composite score for PGR.

Grade C

/ 100

Quality Radar0 – 20 per axis